365 Days

Payne, K.E. 365 Days. Advanced readers copy. Valley Falls, NY: Bold Strokes Books, 2011. Paperback. 194pp. $13.95. ISBN: 978-1-60282-540-6.

Clem is determined to keep her diary up-to-date this year as she explores her changing feelings and dealings with her friends and romantic escapades. She is attracted to her elusive, female classmate J, while her clueless friends try to set her up with Ben. Meanwhile a girl named Hannah moves to town and confuses Clem further.

The reader follows Clem’s comedic musings in her day-by-day diary. Fans of Louise Rennison’s Angus, Thongs, and Full-Frontal Snogging will appreciate similarities between the bumbling, lighthearted heroines confessing their often-failed romantic escapades in diary format. Clem’s awkward antics and indifference towards school will resonate with readers in similar mindsets.

The trouble with 365 Days is the quality of the writing. The prose is such a realistic depiction of how a teenage girl would write a diary that is fails to be art and instead reads like original fan fiction that somehow got published. Clem’s character development also feels stunted and unrealistic. Perhaps her sudden, blind self-declaration of her sexuality is reflective of a changing society, but her thoughts feel like fluff rather than an engaging exploration of a young girl’s life and awakening sexuality. The story seems to be set in the present-day, yet Clem needs to be taught about Facebook by her peers. These details, along with some rambling passages, add up to a clunky novel that distances itself from the audience it is written for.

It is certainly refreshing to read a lighthearted novel that follows a girl as she realizes she is gay and experiences her first love. This novel could have filled a void; it never once delves into the politics of coming-out as a queer teenager or the backlash based on sexuality they often experience. It is a shame that the dull plot and poorly written prose make me unable to recommend this novel for collections in order to fill that void. I have great respect and admiration for what K.E. Payne has done, and hope to see her writing develop over time and produce the novels that I feel she is capable of.

I would only recommend this for public or high school libraries with a very large demand for LGBT literature, despite questionable writing quality.

Reviewed by, Tracy Gossage
MLIS Student
Dominican University

Share

1 comment

  1. Hey, just read you review of 365 Days! I’ve got to say I’m surprised at your comment about the quality of the writing of this book because I’ve just read it and I thought it was awesome!

    The writing was fluid, clever and witty and I thought the whole book was hilarious. To say it never once delved into the politics of coming-out as a queer teenager or the backlash based on sexuality they often experience is strange because the whole point of the book is Clem coming to terms with her sexuality herself first. She takes a while to come out to herself and there’s no backlash becuase no one else (apart from Han waaaay later in the book when she gets it with Hannah) knows she’s gay! And to say that the plot is dull is just weird! The plot fizzes along at a fast pace and is really, really funny.
    A strange review and not one I agree with at all. Sorry, but I really enjoyed 365 Days and would be happy to read a sequel, if the author wrote one.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

Follow Me

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.